[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Responses to comments on draft-ietf-sieve-editheader-00.txt

2005-05-04 07:21:31

Mark E. Mallett writes (about replaceheader)
> To me, it's "pick your evil." One adds to the proliferation of
> extensions, and separates things that really should be together. The
> other delays the standardization of 2/3 of those things.

I think that view is too optimisic. I think the other _prevents_, etc.

If we repeat the 2003 discussion now, what will that change? AFAICT,
nothing. I can't think of anything that has changed in the past two
years, so we'll just spend a few months, arrive at the same conclusion
as last time, and the draft will be x more months delayed.

Speaking as one of the people who wanted replaceheader back, I reluctantly
have to agree with this assessment. Let's move forward with what's there