ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Content-free Last Call comments

2013-06-11 17:03:58
On 10/06/13 21:37, Pete Resnick wrote:
Russ, our IAB chair and former IETF chair, just sent a message to the IETF list regarding a Last Call on draft-ietf-pkix-est. Here is the entire contents of his message, save quoting the whole Last Call request:

On 6/10/13 1:45 PM, Russ Housley wrote:
I have read the document, I a support publication on the standards track.

Russ

Pete,

I write gen-art reviews. A proportion of them at IETF Last Call, give or take a bunch of boilerplate, consist of the word 'Ready'*.

How do you distinguish the usefulness (or otherwise) of such a review from Russ' one liner?

/Elwyn

* and some of the others say 'Not ready' followed by some or many lines of comments.