Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials
2013-07-27 15:37:43
On 28/07/2013 00:23, Dave Crocker wrote:
On 7/27/2013 7:17 AM, Jari Arkko wrote:
"newcomers who attend Working Group meetings are encouraged to
observe and absorb whatever material they can, but should not
interfere with the ongoing process of the group"
...
The first quote might discourage newcomers from participating. I
suggest discussing about the two quotes during the orientation as
they could be misunderstood.
...
But the first one is just plain wrong. Is this from RFC 3184? Many of
the first time IETFers are here for a reason, are well-versed in the
technology in question, and very much able to provide suggestions to
the WG.
It's not wrong.
It's badly worded, possibly bordering on rudeness. It certainly lacks
context. And it probably doesn't apply to BOFs. But it's not wrong.
It reads rudely when taken out of context. But try reading the whole
paragraph in RFC 3184:
IETF participants who attend Working Group meetings read the
relevant Internet-Drafts, RFCs, and e-mail archives beforehand, in
order to familiarize themselves with the technology under
discussion. This may represent a challenge for newcomers, as e-
mail archives can be difficult to locate and search, and it may
not be easy to trace the history of longstanding Working Group
debates. With that in mind, newcomers who attend Working Group
meetings are encouraged to observe and absorb whatever material
they can, but should not interfere with the ongoing process of the
group. Working Group meetings run on a very limited time
schedule, and are not intended for the education of individuals.
The work of the group will continue on the mailing list, and many
questions would be better expressed on the list in the months that
follow.
Exactly. My experience back when I was a newcomer was that it was
easy enough to ask beginner's questions after the meeting, and obviously
wrong to do so during the session. This remains true years later, if I
drop into a WG that I'm not familiar with.
Brian
<Prev in Thread] |
Current Thread |
[Next in Thread>
|
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), (continued)
- Message not available
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), Tim Chown
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), John C Klensin
- Message not available
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), Tim Chown
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), John C Klensin
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), Phillip Hallam-Baker
- Message not available
- Re: dnssdext BOF (was: Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info)), Tim Chown
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info), Abdussalam Baryun
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info), Jari Arkko
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials (was: IETF87 Audio Streaming Info), SM
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Dave Crocker
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials,
Brian E Carpenter <=
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Jari Arkko
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, SM
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Dave Crocker
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Brian Haberman
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, John C Klensin
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Brian E Carpenter
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, joel jaeggli
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, SM
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, t.p.
- Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Keith Moore
|
Previous by Date: |
Re: Oh look! [Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials], Abdussalam Baryun |
Next by Date: |
Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Jari Arkko |
Previous by Thread: |
Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Dave Crocker |
Next by Thread: |
Re: Remote participants, newcomers, and tutorials, Jari Arkko |
Indexes: |
[Date]
[Thread]
[Top]
[All Lists] |
|
|