ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: DMARC stuff

2015-10-22 14:41:39

First, the correct slang term for unsolicited bulk email is "spam",
never "SPAM".  The latter is a product of the Hormel Corporation
and has nothing to do with email; the former is not an acronym and
thus should never be rendered in all-caps.

On Thu, Oct 22, 2015 at 06:41:54PM +0200, JORDI PALET MARTINEZ wrote:
1) IETF is accepting messages from subscribers with MX which are Blacklisted.

Second, blacklisted by *whom*?  There are hundreds of public blacklists
and no doubt several orders of magnitude more private ones.  Some of
these list enormous swaths of network space.  I wouldn't be surprised
if *most* of the messages accepted by IETF mail servers originate from
hosts that are in some blacklist, somewhere.

(Also, I don't think you mean their MX's, necessarily.  You mean
their outbound mail servers, which may or may not be the same as
the hosts listed in their MX records.)

3) Mail servers inspect the IETF and original headers looking for 
black-listed servers.

4) If they are strict, bounce emails from IETF even if the IETF records 
aren???t black-listed but the original sender MX is black-listed

Third, there's your problem.  Don't do that.

If you subscribe to a mailing list, IETF or otherwise, you should accept
all traffic from that mailing list.  It's up to the keepers of the mailing
list to keep it from of spam, which these days isn't all that hard modulo
the occasional compromised list-member account.  And it's up to you to
accept all messages from the mailing list *because you subscribed to it*.

If you don't want to cede authority over list traffic decision-making
to the keepers-of-the-list, then don't subscribe to it.

---rsk

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>