spf-discuss
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: DM News says: MSN requires Sender ID Authentication

2005-06-25 08:37:58
Hector Santos wrote:

Where exactly does any standard propose to create missing
2822 header fields from the envelope for received SMTP data ?
[...]
So what are you exactly asking here?

Which RfC, chapter or page number, says "create missing 2822
header field from the envelope for received SMTP data" ?  You
said that this is a _standard_ claiming authority in the field,
and I want to see where it is, because so far I didn't know it.

Maybe it's in the same RfC where "MDA" is defined, and I don't
have this RfC on my hard disk.  It's also needed for the next
draft-hutzler-spamops.

- Final Destination/storage?

Sure, I know the submit/MSA part, 2476(bis), or the 821/1123
ideas, but what you tested was data without 2822 header fields.

If an odd Sender-ID implementation tries to test a missing PRA
before an ersatz-2822-From is created from the envelope, then
it's just buggy, no surprise.
                              Bye, Frank