ietf-mailsig
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: revised Proposed Charter

2005-07-20 20:35:08

Dave Crocker wrote:

It uses Ned's language concerning restriction of changes to
draft-allman-dkim-*

Is that the following ?

| The working group will make only the minimal changes deemed
| useful to improve the viability of services that are based
| on these specifications

I prefer s/minimal/necessary/ and an option to add other I-Ds
(Murray's, Phil's, or William's) as further input documents.

it states that the working group output will be
standards-track.

I don't see why it can't also create other proposals, it's
up to the IESG to decide about the final status.  No way
to bypass IETF consensus for any WG output => no problem.

| Keys will be stored in the responsible identity's DNS
| hierarchy

Apparently there are other ideas, maybe add "most likely".

                           Bye, Frank



<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>