For what it is worth, I wanted to provide my perspective on this. I of course
believe that it is important that the IETF reaches out to an even more
international participation than it already has. This is first of all because
we really need the views from different types of organisations and different
parts of the world. For instance, I recently had an opportunity to talk to a
number of people about peering in different regions. It really opened my eyes
about how the Internet experience can differ from what I've been used to so
far. We also need to understand how regionally changing requirements for, e.g.,
emergency communications or whitespace management affect our work. Finally, our
international coverage is not just important for our work but also for how we
are perceived. For all of these reasons, reaching out to different parts of the
world is important, and one aspect of that is rotating through meeting
locations around the world.
I would also like to highlight one part of the message from Bob:
The IAOC would
also like to get feedback on how we can ensure the meeting is as successful as
possible and on ways to grow participation in the region.
This is really important, and I hope that we get good feedback on what kinds of
things would be useful to do in order to achieve this. That is, we're not just
asking a binary question if the meeting is or is not ok.
Just meeting in some place does not bring too many new participants, at least
not in a lasting manner. But combined with some other actions, this may be
possible. Are there specific companies or research teams that we could reach
out to, and who might want to be involved in the IETF? Are there local events
where where it would be useful to have someone from the IETF give a talk? Are
there specific IETF or IRTF efforts where we could get more people from South
America involved? Should the ISOC fellows program target something different
than it has so far, or be scaled up? Other ideas?
Jari
P.S. By coincidence, I happened to visit Buenos Aires last year, and found it
to be a fun city. I felt safe and despite not speaking the local language I was
able to talk to the friendly locals, order food, access the network, acquire a
SIM card (albeit with some bureaucratic and technical difficulties, but I think
I can still dig up the MNC numbers that were needed to configure the phone
correctly :-), use the airports, rent a car, and find a Finnish sauna. I think
the city offers all the essential ingredients for life :-)