ietf-mta-filters
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: mostly open issues

1998-11-11 18:09:50
| > Many ISPs run filters on all incoming mail.  Sometimes, forwarding takes
| > place because of infrastructure changes, system changes, etc., on a
| > per-domain basis, especially in a managed messaging environment.  Resent
| > headers should not be inserted because of these system-wide,
| system-imposed
| > filtering rules.
|
| I would not expect Sieve to be used in these cases.  Existing methods
| (for example, .forward) would be used.  Sieve is for conditional,
| message-based actions, during final delivery, on behalf of users.

An example: When one of several domains of users is moved from one mailer to
another, during the migration phase the former will forward mail to the
latter, on a system-wide basis.  Using .forward features, or other per-user
features is neither convenient nor very efficient.

Our product uses Sieve as the system-wide mail filter, specifically for SPAM
filtering, but it is useful to the system administrators for other purposes
as well.

In any case, my principal point was that the "forward" action should not
always insert "Resent-" headers.  I suggested that another action, "resend",
be defined to apply this semantic.

--
Alan K. Stebbens <alan(_dot_)stebbens(_at_)software(_dot_)com>


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>