ietf-openproxy
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: OCP transport vote, commitment

2003-05-11 05:43:20

My vote is:

        ICAP/1.1:        0%
        OCP/OCPTRAN:    80%
        OCP/BEEP:       20%

Initially I was much more in favor of BEEP. One of the main 
reasons to shift my preferences to OCP/OCPTRAN is what Alex 
calls "clone and modify" approach to reusing BEEP mechanisms 
in OCPTRAN. 

Here I'm in favor of reusing not just ideas, but the whole 
sections of the BEEP protocol mechanisms. 

As far as I understand Hilarie has objections against reusing 
BEEP security mechanisms. If this is the case we should make a 
decision on that too.

Oskar