ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Project Proposal: DNS Licensing Look UP - AntiSpam and IP licensing Lookup Additions as text records in DNS

2013-11-19 17:00:14

In message <20131119190303(_dot_)18335(_dot_)qmail(_at_)joyce(_dot_)lan>, "John 
Levine" writes:
There is a need to be able to publish a NO, I DONT WANT YOUR CRAP, DONT
EVEN SEND ME THE FIRST EMAIL, and based on a number of other refusals by
the IESG and IETF Management (based on demands from parties who's sales
of filters may be impacted) has refused to take a formal project to
'provide additions to DNS to allow for the publication of IP Licensing
and US/Contact Information for those domains.

RFC 3665. Nobody ever used it.

I'm fairly sure you mean RFC 3865, "A No Soliciting Simple Mail
Transfer Protocol (SMTP) Service Extension" but you're right, nobody
ever used it.  

We never thought anyone would, but there was political pressure at the
time from people who didn't (and I see some still don't) understand
the "voluntary" part of the way standards work.

R's,
John

If you don't want spam the first thing you need to do is make it
illegal to send unsolicted commercial email both from within a
country to anywhere and to the country regardless of where it is
sent from.  This needs to be done by eventually by all countries
possibly encouraged as part of trade negotiations.

You then need to followup and prosecute offenders.  You need to be
able to fine and/or gaol offenders. You need to be able shutdown
events that are advertised using spam tactics.  You need to be able
to seize products that are advertised using spam tactics.

You need to be able to send a spam complaint to a single national
body which will distribute it to revelent national authorities in
other juristictions.

This won't stop all spam, but will reduce the amount of spam from
legitimate advertisers.

Mark
-- 
Mark Andrews, ISC
1 Seymour St., Dundas Valley, NSW 2117, Australia
PHONE: +61 2 9871 4742                 INTERNET: marka(_at_)isc(_dot_)org

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>