ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: on recurring favourite locations for November IETF meetings

2014-11-11 11:52:13
Folks,

Yes, there are all sorts of things you can do to be able to apply for
visa, but that does not relly cut to the heart of the question.

Why do we place our meetings at places where it takes ridiculously long
time to not have your visa approved on time!

Looking at the Chinese example, there are 119 registered from China,
and about 70 (maybe 80) of those are here. The main reason is that
they can't travel because of visa.

Now of the 70 (or 80) that are here a fair number are here because they
earlier applied for 1-year multiple entry visas.

This makes the percentage that applied for but did not get a visa very
close to 50%.

Draw you own conclusions!

/Loa


On 2014-11-11 12:10, Christer Holmberg wrote:
Hi,

If a reservation is needed in order to get the visa, some people book a 
refundable ticket for the visa application. Then, when/if they get the visa, 
they cancel the ticket and buy a new, cheaper non-refundable ticket.

(Of course, if the visa is accepted very close to the meeting, cheaper tickets 
may not be available anymore.)

There are also so called cancel-for-any-reason travel insurances. Not sure if 
they cover the whole cost of the ticket, but afaik at least a major part.

Regards,

Christer

-----Original Message-----
From: ietf [mailto:ietf-bounces(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org] On Behalf Of John C Klensin
Sent: 11 November 2014 11:46
To: Fernando Gont; Michael Richardson; 'IAOC'; 'IETF Discussion'
Subject: Re: on recurring favourite locations for November IETF meetings



--On Monday, November 10, 2014 17:57 -1000 Fernando Gont 
<fernando(_at_)gont(_dot_)com(_dot_)ar> wrote:

...
Do airlines give full refunds if you don't get a VISA, I doubt it.

Not at all.

Not unless one buys fully refundable tickets, of course - see below.

...
IIRC, in most cases, what they require is an  itinerary/reservation
rather than a ticket.

If a reservation is required, it can be almost equivalent to requiring a ticket, since 
many airlines won't hold a reservation for a cheap/ refundable ticket for very long 
without buying the ticket.  "Not very long" can be as short as hours.  
Sometimes, one can buy a reservation hold for a longer period (72 hours, a week, ...) but 
that price, while much lower that than of a ticket, is typically non-refundable if one 
does not end up buying the ticket (and sometimes even if one does).

The problem here is that, as you note, you have two options:

1) Buy the ticket prior to getting the visa -- with the risk of not
getting it in time and hence wasting the ticket/money, or,

2) Wait till you get the visa before buying the ticket -- at which
point the ticket prices can be insane.

(3) Buy a fully-refundable ticket, whose advance-purchase price may or may not be 
significantly lower than late purchase, "Insane" prices but will certainly be a 
lot more than the non-refundable ones you refer to in (1).

All the above sad, I should say that, as far as
central/south-americans are concerned, e.g. Europe tends to be way
more friendly than North America: I can travel anywhere in Europe
(except Russia, I think) without a visa... but need a visa for US and
Canada.

Unfortunately, generalizing from any given country or regional experience is not 
helpful.  As an example, a few central/south american countries reciprocate US 
and/or Canada visa requirements and procedures, not only requiring visas, but 
pulling the same "we will not formally turn you down, but may keep your 
application in a 'processing' state until the time of the meeting or other event, or 
at least the plausible airfare
window, has passed".   I speak from experience, having had
Brazilian and Chinese visa applications timed out despite allowing lots of 
application time.

Also note that there are country pairs in which the destination country may be 
very relaxed about tourist visas (or waivers for
tourists) but may require formal visas for business or meeting attendance.  A subset of them do 
make an effort to keep track and react very harshly to someone entering as a tourist and then doing 
business/ professional stuff.  One thing I think no one wants is to have to answer a future 
"have you ever been deported from a country or denied entry because of visa or immigration 
violations" question with "yes".

Generalizations are _very_ risky.

Michael's conclusions are, IMO, the correct ones.  I would restate them as:

(1) Do not experiment with November meetings.  Pick places where we at least 
know what we are getting into.

(2) Do not pick locations that are known for being tourist destinations -- they 
can make consular officials nervous in ways that locations where no sane person 
would go except on business do not... and nervousness often results in visa 
delays.

(3) Set things up so that people have _lots_ of time for dealing with the 
slowest and more conservative of processes.  That probably includes not only 
getting our invitation letters out early, but having experts design them for 
maximum persuasiveness and probably individualizing them more than I assume we 
have been doing (but I don't know, having never seen one).

     john


       john





<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>