I totally agree with Avri's point.
IETF claims that IETF trys to avoid his STD activity to be affected by big
comapanies.
With the increasing of registration fee year by year (many years ago, it
is 550 usd), only IETFers supported by big company can easily
join the meeting. The IETFers who are self-funded or funded by small
comany will not easily join the meeting.
For big company, the registration fee whether it is 1000 usd or 700 usd is
a small money, but it is a "big" money for individuals or small companies.
so if the registration fee is increased every few years, is it possible
that in some days only IETFers supported by big company or "rich" IETFers
can
join the face-2-face meeting, other "poor" people can only join it
remotely?
does it mean that the future IETF STD activity has to be affected by big
comanies seriously?
I think that we need to find other finance resource to support IETF's
activity.
For example, put the paypal donation button in every rfc. everyone after
reading the rfc can choose to donate some money to IETF's account.
I think that we might learn some wikipedia's donation mechanism.
------------------------------
Jiankang Yao
*From:* Avri Doria <javascript:_e(%7B%7D,'cvml','avri(_at_)acm(_dot_)org');>
*Date:* 2014-10-02 11:50
*To:* ietf <javascript:_e(%7B%7D,'cvml','ietf(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org');>
*Subject:* Re: IETF registration fee increase from 2015
Hi,
Ouch!
Doesn't this move the IETF a bit further along the scale of meetings
that can only be afforded by corporates and rich people.
At some point, the openness of a task force, or other organizational
entity, depends on its cost.
Isn't the Internet Society able to adequately support the IETF? I
thought that was one of its primary missions.
Personally I think fees should go down and not up.
avri
On 01-Oct-14 10:43, IETF Chair wrote:
In preparing the final budget for 2015 and drafts for 2016 and beyond,
we face continuing rising meeting and other costs and no corresponding
increase in meeting registration fees. In fact, the meeting
registration fee has not changed in 4 years.
Therefore, the IAOC is proposing to raise the meeting registration fee
by $50 per meeting starting with the March meeting in Dallas as
follows:
Early Bird Fee $650 to $700, or 8%
Late Fee $800 to $850
Day Passes $350 to $400
Full time Students $150 - $175
More details below, but we seek community feedback before doing this.
The cause for the increase is a trend in rising costs. IETF costs relate
to the
meetings, support services (secretariat, IT), RFC Editor, and various other
items such as tool development. IETF is funded through the meeting fees, as
well as significant contributions through sponsors and ISOC.
For the last 4 years, 2011 - 2014, the Registration Fee has been unchanged
at $650, and for the period 2008 through 2010 the Registration Fee was $635.
Over the period 2007 through 2014 the Registration Fee increased from $600
to $650, 8.3% over the eight years. During that time Expenses, including
meetings, RFC Editor, Secretariat, IASA, and others, increased 32%. In 2015
Expenses will increase 6% over the 2014 forecast.
As a percentage contribution to the budget, registration revenue has
declined
from 51% in 2007 to 41% in 2014. Without a registration fee increase in
2015, that would drop to 36% of the budget. Even with the fee increase of
$50 in 2015, it becomes 39%.
Since the implementation of IASA in 2005, the IAOC has sought to provide
support services of high quality and value through a 搑egularization?of
contractual relationship with our vendors in all the above categories. As
you
know, we submit statements of work to the community for review and do
competitive Requests for Proposals. Our services continue to change, and in
some cases expand, such as increasing the number of editors to handle the
roughly 340 RFCs per year, outsourcing the NOC, and remote participation
services.
The suggested registration fee increase is sufficient to re-balance the
budget
for 2015. Unfortunately, the cost of hotel facilities and other services
continues
to grow slowly. Without further actions, additional increases may be
necessary,
and we project a $20 increase for 2016. The IAOC has taken on a task to
determine whether we can reduce and/or prioritize our costs so that the
trend
can be minimized. No decisions have been taken about meeting fees beyond
2015, and they will depend on the success of the IAOC in its task.
The draft budget, registration fee history, expense history and major
expense
trends can be found here: <https://iaoc.ietf.org/2015-budget.html>.
Thanks for your consideration of this and your feedback. The next IAOC
meeting
is October 9th, and if possible, we would prefer to receive feedback by then
Jari Arkko, IETF Chair
Chris Griffiths, IAOC Chair